🔗 Share this article

This luxuriously rich meat-free dish, often described as a cousin of butter chicken, represents one of the highly popular creations in South Asian cooking. Chef a renowned chef refers to it as “the top and most adapted dish in India,” while fellow chefs note its consistent appeal in dining spots all over India.

If you have yet to experience the crowd-pleasing allure of homemade curd cheese in a gentle gravy, these instructions presents a perfect chance to give it a try. Paneer makhni (butter being the Hindi word for butter) seems surprisingly sophisticated, but it’s relatively simple and fast to prepare. Accompany with naan and a fresh salad to create a complete meal.

The Paneer

For many home chefs, this unsalted, soft cheese occupies a comparable role as firm bean curd, serving as a pleasingly firm nutritious element with a mildly rich profile that flatters, rather than clashes with, any gravy it’s served in. It's possible to create from scratch Indian cottage cheese using full-fat milk and vinegar, or buy it easily sourced at international markets and larger supermarkets.

A few methods involve marinating the cheese before cooking, often with a spice blend that gives an appetising red colour. However, firm commercial paneer can be very compact to soak up marinade, so seasoning is often improved with a freshly made cheese.

Different methods suggest browning the cubes before mixing with the sauce. One popular version tosses the cubes in a blend of minced garlic, fresh ginger, chilli powder, lemon juice, seasoning, turmeric, and dairy, like the technique used for chicken makhni. The cheese is then roasted or pan-fried to create a golden crust.

By contrast, several experts choose to fold in the cubes at the last moment of simmering. This method maintains the distinction between the soft, neutral quality of the cubes and the decadent, aromatic gravy. If you’re enjoying a stronger flavour in the protein, baking is worth trying.

Preparing the Gravy

The foundation of this creamy curry often begins with sliced onion, fresh ginger, and crushed garlic. Certain formulas feature deeply browned onion to enhance the natural sugar, while alternatives depend on aromatic pastes alone. The dairy in paneer makhni impart a distinct sweetness that pairs well with softened onion and root ginger.

In terms of spices, the dish often contains a short list of common Indian spices: yellow spice, red pepper, green cardamom, and garam masala are popular picks. Some versions incorporate toasted cumin, fresh coriander, mace, or a tej patta. The aromatic quality of cardamom pods pairs beautifully with the decadence of butter, while the aromatic elements in the spice blend enhance the final result.

Methi leaves, often stirred in near the finish, are seen as a must for their distinctive bitter, slightly woody taste that provides character to the curry. This ingredient can make a significant difference in the final dish, similar to its use in other rich sauces.

For the tomatoes, a even, lush feel is ideal. If using fresh tomatoes, it can help to puree them with a food processor or strain them to create a lump-free gravy. Otherwise, opting for finely chopped tomatoes can save time.

If you don’t possess full-bodied fresh tomatoes, it’s advisable to skip them, as inferior fruit can result in a weak, sharp gravy. Several methods additionally use a bit of tomato paste to intensify the depth of flavour. A touch of honey may be added to offset the sharpness, with alternatives like granulated sugar or natural sweetener based on taste.

The Dairy

Reflecting its name, rich butter is a central ingredient in paneer makhni, but several versions use additionally other dairy products to boost the decadent feel. A few experts include Greek yoghurt, heavy cream, {single cream|light cream|pour